By Todd Bevington | Scotsman Guide (abridged)
For years, homeowners insurance has largely been treated as a routine final step in the mortgage process — something borrowers secure shortly before closing to satisfy lender requirements. But that approach is becoming harder to sustain.
In many parts of the country, insurance costs are beginning to reshape housing affordability altogether. Borrowers who once focused primarily on mortgage rates and monthly principal and interest payments are now concerned with rising premiums, stricter underwriting standards and reduced carrier availability that can materially change the total cost of homeownership.
Some carriers have become more selective about the homes and markets they are willing to insure. In certain cases, borrowers discover coverage challenges late in the transaction process after inspections, appraisals and rate locks are already complete.
For mortgage originators, that delayed timing creates a problem. A borrower who appeared financially qualified early in the process may later encounter insurance costs that significantly alter monthly payments, escrow obligations or overall affordability.
With higher rebuilding costs, evolving severe weather exposure and changing risk models, insurance can no longer sit quietly in the background of the transaction. In some markets, it is becoming part of the affordability conversation from the beginning.
That shift is forcing many mortgage professionals to rethink where insurance enters the borrower journey. One emerging solution is embedded insurance. Instead of treating insurance as a separate, last-minute transaction, embedded insurance integrates guidance and coverage options directly into the mortgage process early in the approval stage through a licensed insurance broker.
The evolving affordability equation
Many borrowers still think about affordability primarily through the mortgage payment itself. But the true cost of homeownership has always been a three-legged stool: the mortgage payment, property taxes and homeowners insurance. Each piece can change independently, yet together they shape the borrower’s total monthly housing cost.
Today, taxes and insurance are rising quickly — and in some markets, such as Florida and Texas, faster than mortgage payments themselves. In fact, ICE Mortgage Technology data shows that homeowners insurance costs have increased 72% nationally since 2019, while property taxes have risen more than 31% over the same period. Moreover, taxes and insurance accounted for 32% of the average single-family mortgage payment in September 2025 — the highest share since ICE began tracking the data in 2014.
For some buyers, the reality of high monthly carrying costs does not fully become clear until late in the transaction. Borrowers who initially feel comfortable with projected monthly payments may later discover that rising taxes and insurance premiums can still increase escrow payments over time — even with a fixed-rate mortgage.
These rising costs are affecting transaction certainty. In a Realtor.com survey, 30% of current homebuyers said they have changed the geographic region they are searching in due to homeowners insurance costs, while nearly 25% shifted their homebuying strategy for the same reason. That can create real pressure for originators trying to keep transactions moving at a critical point in the process.
Read More (subscriber content)
Some stories may only appear as partial reprints because of publisher restrictions.